Buffalo’s Top 3 Pizza Spots Serving Up Slices Faster Than a Lake-Effect Snowstorm

In Buffalo, three pizzerias stand out for their rapid service and delectable slices. Jay's Artisan Pizza impresses with its wood-fired Neapolitan-style pies, reflecting a commitment to artisan techniques. Bocce Club Pizza, a beloved fixture since 1946, serves flavorful offerings with original recipes, ensuring quality ingredients in every bite. Finally, Picasso's Pizza offers a crispy, Buffalo-style favorite, famed for its customization and family legacy. Each place not only excels in speed but also enriches Buffalo's vibrant culinary scene. Discover the unique stories and mouthwatering specialties these pizzerias have to offer, waiting just around the corner.

Key Takeaways

  • Jay's Artisan Pizza is renowned for its quick service, offering wood-fired pizzas with a modern twist in a welcoming atmosphere.
  • Bocce Club Pizza has been a local favorite since 1946, providing a range of traditional bocce pizzas available in multiple sizes for fast dining.
  • Picasso's Pizza specializes in Buffalo-style pizza and emphasizes takeout and delivery, ensuring speedy service for customers on the go.
  • All three establishments prioritize quality ingredients and unique recipes, enhancing the overall dining experience while maintaining efficient service.
  • Buffalo's pizza scene thrives on these top spots, each contributing to the city's reputation with their quick, delicious offerings.

Jay's Artisan Pizza

In the vibrant landscape of Buffalo's culinary scene, Jay's Artisan Pizza stands out as a hallmark of quality and innovation. Founded in 2017 by Jay Langfelder, this pizzeria has quickly risen to prominence, initially capturing attention with its wood-fired techniques honed through the OG Wood Fire food truck. Now operated by the ambitious Joe Powers, who took the reins at just 21, Jay's Artisan Pizza embraces the essence of Neapolitan flavors while infusing a modern flair into classic pizza offerings.

Each pie is a celebration of craftsmanship, featuring an extended fermentation process that elevates the dough to new heights of flavor and texture. Signature creations like the award-winning 'NDUJA pizza showcase a harmonious blend of Temepsta 'nduja, fontal cheese, red onion, chili honey, and fresh basil, tantalizing taste buds and embodying the spirit of culinary freedom. With accolades including rankings among the best pizzerias in the U.S., Jays Artisan Pizza ranked No. 6 Best Pizzeria by 50 Top Pizza USA in June 2023, it is not just a dining destination; it is a movement, inviting guests to experience the art of pizza in a welcoming, neighborhood atmosphere.

Here, every bite is a tribute to tradition and innovation.

Bocce Club Pizza

Bocce Club Pizza, a cherished establishment in Buffalo's pizza landscape, boasts a rich history that dates back to 1946. Founded by Dino Pacciotti after WWII, it originated at the Bocce Club on Hickory Street, which featured bocce ball courts and served drinks and sandwiches.

It was here that Pacciotti discovered an old pizza oven in the basement, leading to the creation of his unique bocce recipes that would become a local favorite. In 1959, Bocce Club Pizza relocated to Bailey Avenue in Amherst, followed by another location in Williamsville in 1988.

To fully appreciate what Bocce Club Pizza has to offer, consider the following:

  1. Original Bocce Pizzas: Available in quarter, half, and whole sizes, catering to all appetites.
  2. Specialty Pizzas: Indulge in favorites such as Bocce's Deluxe, Hawaiian, and Vegetarian.
  3. Appetizers and Sides: Complement your meal with mozzarella sticks, garlic bread, or chicken wings.

With nationwide delivery and a commitment to quality, Bocce Club Pizza continues to be a significant part of Buffalo's pizza history, delighting patrons with its flavorful offerings. Additionally, their menu includes a variety of options, ensuring that you can enjoy a taste of Buffalo food no matter where you are in the U.S.

Picasso's Pizza

Nestled within Buffalo's vibrant pizza scene, Picasso's Pizza stands out as a tribute to family tradition and culinary artistry. Founded by the DiGiore family, whose roots trace back to 1915, this beloved establishment honors its Italian heritage with recipes passed down through generations.

Fioravante DiGiore, an immigrant laborer, began the family's entrepreneurial journey by crafting Italian cookies and pizzas in his home, a legacy that continues to thrive today.

Picasso's is renowned for its Buffalo-style pizza, characterized by a light and crispy crust and topped with locally made mozzarella, sweet tomato sauce, and hand-cut pepperoni cups, charred to perfection. They also offer customization options for crust and toppings, ensuring every customer can enjoy their perfect slice.

Their menu extends beyond pizza, offering chicken wings, subs, and other Italian delights, all reflecting the rich tapestry of Buffalo flavors.

With multiple locations throughout the region, Picasso's has adapted to changing times, focusing on takeout and delivery services that guarantee their cherished recipes remain accessible to the community.

While reviews highlight occasional cooking inconsistencies, the pizzeria's commitment to quality and the enduring DiGiore traditions solidify its reputation as a local staple in Western New York's pizza landscape.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Are the Operating Hours for These Pizzerias?

The operating hours for these pizzerias typically extend from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM on weekends, with peak times often occurring during lunch and dinner. Always check individual websites for potential variations in hours.

Do Any of These Pizzerias Offer Gluten-Free Options?

While these esteemed pizzerias delight patrons with their signature flavors, they currently do not offer gluten-free crusts or health-conscious toppings, focusing instead on traditional recipes that celebrate the rich culinary heritage of pizza.

Is Delivery Available for All Three Pizza Spots?

Delivery availability varies among the three pizza spots. While La Nova likely offers delivery, Jay's Artisan Pizza and Bocce Club Pizza require direct inquiries to confirm delivery fees and times, ensuring a tailored dining experience.

Are There Vegetarian or Vegan Menu Options?

The pizza spots offer limited vegetarian toppings, but specific vegan cheese options are not explicitly available. Customization might accommodate both dietary preferences, though clarity on specific offerings would enhance the dining experience for conscious consumers.

Can I Order Online or Through a Mobile App?

In an age where convenience reigns supreme, online ordering and mobile apps enhance the culinary experience. While Picasso's Pizza embraces technology for effortless access, Jay's Artisan and Bocce Club require traditional methods for their delectable offerings.

Conclusion

In the vibrant tapestry of Buffalo's culinary scene, three pizzerias stand out, each offering a unique slice of pizza perfection. Jay's Artisan Pizza captivates with its creative toppings, while Bocce Club Pizza tempts with its legendary crust. Picasso's Pizza, with its artistic flair, elevates the pizza experience. As winter approaches, the anticipation of savoring these delectable slices intensifies, creating an irresistible urge to explore the flavors that await. Will these pizzerias exceed expectations and warm the soul amidst the snow?

More Pizza Content For You