Columbus's pizza scene shines with three standout establishments. Rubino's Pizzeria, a nostalgic gem since 1954, is celebrated for its crunchy thin crust and diverse topping selections. The Pizza House, rooted in tradition since 1961, offers authentic flavors with a family atmosphere that fosters loyalty. Meanwhile, Dewey's Pizza captivates with its thick-crust options and innovative toppings, including unique flavor combinations like Brussels sprouts and caramelized onions. Each pizzeria not only guarantees speedy delivery but also delivers remarkable taste. To uncover more about what makes these spots exceptional, the journey continues into their distinctive offerings and community impact.
Key Takeaways
- Rubino's Pizzeria offers quality, flavorful pizzas with a nostalgic atmosphere and speedy carry-out service, ensuring a delightful dining experience.
- The Pizza House features authentic Italian recipes and quick delivery, known for its loyal following and comforting traditional dishes.
- Dewey's Pizza specializes in innovative flavors and gluten-free options, paired with fast service to enhance the overall dining experience.
- All three pizzerias boast solid reputations, providing delicious offerings and convenient ordering methods to satisfy local pizza lovers.
- Each establishment emphasizes community connection, making them top choices for quick, tasty pizza in Columbus.
Rubino's Pizzeria: A Columbus Classic
What makes Rubino's Pizzeria a beloved institution in Columbus? Established in 1954, this Bexley gem has become a cornerstone of the local culinary heritage, operating for over 69 years.
Its rich history offers patrons more than just pizza; it provides a nostalgic experience steeped in tradition. Diners are treated to a no-nonsense, old-school atmosphere that transports them to a simpler time, where the focus remains on quality and taste. The Binos app provided by Homage enhances the convenience for customers looking to order from local favorites like Rubino's.
Rubino's menu highlights include a variety of pizzas, available in small (10") and large (14") sizes, with prices ranging from $8.50 to $16.26. The selection of toppings—ranging from classic cheese and pepperoni to more adventurous options like anchovies—caters to diverse palates.
Beyond pizza, the restaurant serves comforting spaghetti, meatballs, and ravioli dinners, ensuring there's something for everyone.
With a solid 4.5-star rating on Tripadvisor and recognition among the 25-best pizzerias in Columbus, Rubino's crunchy thin crust pizza stands out.
As a cash-only establishment with dine-in and carry-out options, it embodies the freedom of choice for every pizza lover, making it a must-visit for both locals and visitors alike.
The Pizza House: Tradition and Taste
Nestled in a cozy corner of Columbus, The Pizza House has been a cherished establishment since its inception in 1961, offering a unique blend of tradition and taste that resonates with both longtime patrons and newcomers alike. Founded by cousins Richie Dorn and Bobby Tiberi, the restaurant began in a modest house, where its original recipes quickly garnered a loyal following.
Today, the menu showcases an array of traditional Italian dishes, with pizza reigning supreme as the number one seller. The Pizza House has also expanded its offerings to include catering services, accommodating local corporate clients and further enhancing its community presence.
What sets The Pizza House apart is its unwavering commitment to maintaining the original recipes, ensuring that each bite reflects the essence of authentic Italian cuisine. The unique taste of their dough, combined with dishes like veal parmesan and lasagna, creates a culinary experience that transports diners to a simpler time.
The family atmosphere extends beyond the menu; staff members, some with decades of service, treat every customer like family, fostering deep connections and community loyalty.
With many patrons traveling great distances to savor its offerings, The Pizza House remains a showcase to the enduring power of tradition and the taste that keeps people coming back for more.
Dewey's Pizza: Thick-Crust Delight
At the heart of Columbus, Dewey's Pizza stands out as a haven for pizza lovers seeking a thick-crust delight that marries quality ingredients with innovative flavors. Nestled at 1327 West 5th Avenue, this pizzeria offers an inviting atmosphere complemented by its extensive menu, featuring the classic Dewey's Original and the adventurous Van Damme.
Each pizza is a demonstration of culinary creativity, showcasing bold topping combinations such as Brussels sprouts, caramelized onions, and bacon, ensuring that every bite is an explosion of taste. Dewey's commitment to inclusivity shines through with gluten-free options, allowing those with dietary restrictions to indulge without compromise. The Create Your Own Pizza option further empowers guests to personalize their dining experience, selecting from a variety of sauces and toppings that cater to diverse palates.
Open daily with varied hours, Dewey's provides not just pizzas but also a selection of craft brews and wines, enhancing the overall experience. With carryout service available, enjoying a thick-crust masterpiece at home is always an option. Reviews can be left on multiple platforms, ensuring that Dewey's continues to thrive on customer feedback.
Dewey's Pizza is more than a dining choice; it's a celebration of flavor, creativity, and community.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Are the Most Popular Toppings at Each Pizza Place?
The most popular toppings at these establishments reflect regional favorites, including pepperoni and sausage. Unusual combinations, such as mushrooms and green peppers, enhance the traditional offerings, appealing to diverse palates and culinary preferences within Columbus.
Do Any of These Places Offer Vegan Pizza Options?
When it comes to satisfying vegan appetites, each establishment presents a unique landscape. Dewey's allows for plant-based toppings, while Hounddog's offers flexible customization, though neither prominently features vegan cheese. Terita's remains traditional, lacking vegan options.
What Are the Hours of Operation for These Pizzerias?
The hours of operation for these pizzerias are consistent, generally open from 11am to 10pm on weekdays, extending to 11pm on weekends. Customer reviews highlight efficient delivery times and a welcoming atmosphere throughout these hours.
Is There Outdoor Seating Available at Any of These Locations?
Currently, none of the top pizzerias in Columbus explicitly mention outdoor seating availability. Each location focuses on delivery experience and patio ambiance, enhancing the enjoyment of gourmet pizzas in a cozy, inviting setting.
Are There Any Gluten-Free Options at These Pizzerias?
Despite the growing demand for gluten-free options—over 30% of diners seeking gluten-free ingredients—none of the highlighted pizzerias in Columbus explicitly offer such alternatives, raising concerns about potential cross-contamination for gluten-sensitive customers.
Conclusion
To sum up, the culinary journey through Columbus's pizza landscape reveals a delightful trifecta of options, each vying for supremacy in both flavor and delivery speed. Rubino's Pizzeria stands as a nostalgic beacon, while The Pizza House champions time-honored traditions. Dewey's Pizza, with its audacious thick crust, boldly challenges conventional expectations. Therefore, the quest for the perfect slice in Columbus resembles a high-stakes culinary Olympics, where taste buds, rather than athletes, vie for gold in gastronomic glory.
