Columbus's pizza landscape is rich and diverse, showcasing pizzerias that cater to every palate. Paulie Gee's serves artisanal wood-fired creations, while Terita's Pizza charms with its signature square-cut style. Dewey's Pizza is celebrated for its vibrant atmosphere and customizable options, and Harvest Pizzeria highlights locally sourced ingredients in gourmet offerings. Natalie's Coal Fired Pizza achieves distinctive flavors with its unique coal-fired technique. Adriatico's Pizza offers a beloved New York-style experience. Whether you crave inventive toppings or classic pies, Columbus has something for every pizza lover. For a thorough look at the best local spots, explore further insights into these pizzerias.
Paulie Gee's
When it comes to finding exceptional pizza in Columbus, Paulie Gee's stands out as a must-visit destination. This Brooklyn-based pizzeria brings an artisanal touch to the Short North, showcasing the craftsmanship of a skilled wood-fired pizzaiolo. The menu features a rotating selection of classic and innovative pies, including a commendable array of vegan options that cater to diverse palates. Significantly, the cashew milk topping on the Red, White, and Greenpeace Pizza exemplifies the restaurant's commitment to inclusivity in flavor. The ambiance, enriched by reclaimed barn wood and local photographs, enhances the overall dining experience. With a reputation bolstered by critical acclaim, Paulie Gee's is undeniably a cornerstone of Columbus's pizza scene, inviting freedom of choice for all pizza lovers. Additionally, Paulie Gee's is located in the Short North Arts District, which is known for its vibrant culture and art.
Terita's Pizza
Terita's Pizza distinguishes itself with its unique square-cut style, offering a delightful twist on traditional pizza presentation. This approach not only enhances the visual appeal but also allows for a more even distribution of toppings, guaranteeing each bite is as flavorful as the last. Additionally, Terita's commitment to affordability guarantees that patrons can enjoy high-quality, delicious pizza without breaking the bank. With a legacy of 60 years of consistent service, Terita's has established itself as a beloved staple in the Columbus pizza scene.
Unique Square-Cut Style
At the heart of Columbus's pizza scene lies a distinct culinary tradition exemplified by the unique square-cut style of Terita's Pizza.
This family-run legacy, established in 1959, showcases a commitment to quality and community. The square cut tradition, also known as tavern or party cut, allows for a generous distribution of toppings from edge to edge, enhancing the dining experience. Terita's thin crust strikes a perfect balance, providing a delightful base for classic and specialty options alike. Customer reviews reflect appreciation for the consistent quality and the iconic Ezzo pepperoni. The restaurant is particularly renowned for its generous topping options, which elevate the flavor profiles of each pizza.
In a city rich with culinary diversity, Terita's stands out as a quintessential neighborhood spot, symbolizing both resilience and the enduring joy of shared meals.
Affordable and Flavorful Options
Columbus's pizza enthusiasts often seek out establishments that offer both affordability and exceptional flavor, and Terita's Pizza excels in this regard.
With a menu featuring budget-friendly options, including pizzas, subs, and wings, Terita's delivers large portions adorned with delicious toppings like pepperoni, sausage, and vibrant green peppers.
Their signature sauce, known for its unique kick, enhances each bite and complements the thin, crispy crust perfectly. Consistently high-quality ingredients guarantee a satisfying experience that keeps customers coming back for more. Additionally, customers appreciate the friendly service that contributes to a pleasant dining experience.
The friendly, efficient take-out service and easy online ordering further elevate the experience, making Terita's a beloved local favorite.
Its impressive collection of glowing reviews solidifies its reputation as a go-to spot for pizza lovers seeking both value and flavor.
Dewey's Pizza
Dewey's Pizza stands out as a notable contender in the competitive landscape of Columbus pizzerias, combining a diverse menu with a commitment to quality ingredients. With a rich history rooted in community engagement, Dewey's ambiance invites customers to indulge in a casual yet vibrant dining experience. Notably, the menu features a variety of specialty pizzas such as the Bronx Bomber and Killer Veggie, appealing to various tastes.
| Menu Highlights | Pricing |
|---|---|
| Dewey's Original | 11" – $11.50 |
| Van Damme | 11" – $18.50 |
| Calzone | Customizable |
Dewey's offers customizable options, ensuring that every pizza reflects individual tastes. Ranked #16 in Columbus, its dedication to quality has garnered national attention. The lively atmosphere, complemented by a selection of salads and gluten-free offerings, makes Dewey's a beloved spot for locals seeking flavorful freedom in their dining choices.
Harvest Pizzeria
Harvest Pizzeria has emerged as the pinnacle of pizza excellence in Columbus, celebrated for its commitment to quality and innovation.
Renowned for its wood-fired technique, this pizzeria utilizes gourmet ingredients sourced from local farms, ensuring every bite bursts with flavor. Additionally, guests can stay updated on events and promotions by signing up for their newsletter, which ensures they receive only relevant content tailored to their interests.
Highlights of the menu include:
- Wood-Fired Pizzas: Featuring unique options like Almond Pesto and Quattro Formaggi.
- Small Plates: Complement your meal with Buffalo Cauliflower or Brussels Sprouts.
- Diverse Offerings: Satisfy every palate with salads, sandwiches, and delightful desserts such as Butterscotch Budino.
With multiple locations and a vibrant atmosphere, Harvest Pizzeria stands out not just for its pizza but for an immersive dining experience that resonates with freedom and creativity.
Natalie's Coal Fired Pizza
Natalie's Coal Fired Pizza stands out in the Columbus pizza scene with its unique coal-fired cooking method, which reaches temperatures around 1000 degrees, resulting in pizzas with perfectly blistered crusts. The menu features signature offerings that highlight fresh ingredients, including house-made mozzarella and seasonal produce sourced from the local Worthington Farmers Market. This commitment to quality and authenticity not only enhances the dining experience but also elevates Natalie's to a distinguished position among the best pizzerias in the area. Additionally, guests can enjoy live music during Happening Hour, creating a vibrant atmosphere perfect for savoring their delicious pizzas.
Unique Cooking Method
At the forefront of Columbus's culinary scene, the unique cooking method employed by Natalie's Coal Fired Pizza sets it apart from traditional pizzerias. Utilizing coal fired techniques in an Earthstone oven, they achieve remarkable high heat benefits, reaching temperatures up to 1,000 degrees.
This innovative approach guarantees:
- Distinct Flavor: The anthracite coal imparts a unique taste that enhances the overall pizza experience.
- Crispy Crust: High heat creates a perfectly crispy crust, characteristic of Neapolitan-style pizzas.
- Rapid Cooking: Each pizza cooks in under two minutes, preserving the freshness of ingredients. Additionally, grilling pizza at high temperatures ensures that the dough cooks quickly, achieving that sought-after Neapolitan style.
The meticulous temperature management and careful seasoning of the oven illustrate a commitment to quality, allowing Natalie's to deliver pizzas that are not only delicious but also consistently exceptional.
Signature Menu Offerings
A diverse array of signature menu offerings at Natalie's Coal Fired Pizza showcases the restaurant's commitment to quality and innovation in each dish.
The Margherita Pizza, with its fresh mozzarella and basil, pays homage to traditional flavors, while the High St. Casa Pizza presents a hearty blend of Italian sausage, bacon, and pepperoni, perfect for meat lovers.
Seasonal ingredients shine in their rotating Seasonal Pizza, emphasizing freshness and local produce.
Complementing the pizzas, small plates like Arancini and Duck Fat Popcorn tantalize the palate.
The ambiance is enriched by live music performances, creating a vibrant dining experience that celebrates culinary artistry and community spirit.
Natalie's not only serves exceptional pizza but also fosters a space for enjoyment and connection, making it a popular spot for live music lovers in the area.
Martha's Fusion Kitchen
Although often celebrated for its vibrant atmosphere and unique culinary offerings, Martha's Fusion Kitchen has carved out a distinct niche in Columbus's food scene, particularly with its innovative take on traditional dishes.
This restaurant stands out for its unique fusion of flavors, especially in its birria tacos and birria quesadilla. Patrons rave about the following highlights:
- Pizzadilla: A delightful blend of birria, cheese, cilantro, and onions, encased in two 12" flour tortillas.
- Mulitas: A flavorful twist on classic tacos, delivering depth in every bite.
- Chiles Rellenos: A savory option worth inquiring about.
With a stellar rating of 4.6/5 on Yelp, Martha's promises an unforgettable culinary experience that transcends typical pizza offerings. The restaurant is especially known for its freshly cooked meals, often prepared with a wait time of approximately 10 minutes.
Adriatico's Pizza
Martha's Fusion Kitchen showcases creative culinary fusions, yet Adriatico's Pizza stands as a symbol of the classic New York-style pizza experience that has garnered a loyal following in Columbus.
With a rich pizza history, Adriatico's embraces traditional techniques while adapting to modern topping trends, offering options like the Margherita and Six Cheese pizzas. The choice between thin and thick crust caters to diverse preferences, enhancing the dining experience for both OSU students and local residents.
Renowned for its inviting atmosphere, especially for dine-in, Adriatico's has solidified its place among the top pizzerias in Columbus.
Whether indulging in appetizers or pasta, each visit promises a flavorful journey through the essence of authentic pizza craftsmanship.
OH Pizza Brew
For those seeking a dynamic pizza experience in Columbus, OH Pizza Brew stands out with its innovative menu that marries traditional flavors with contemporary twists.
The pizzeria excels in crafting unique pies that cater to adventurous palates, prominently featuring Buffalo Sauce as a key ingredient.
Highlights include:
- Buffalo Pizza: A delicious combination of chicken, bleu cheese crumbles, and a ranch drizzle.
- Fire Starter Pizza: A spicy medley with taco chicken, jalapeños, and Cheddar Jack.
- BBQ Chicken Pizza: A savory blend of BBQ sauce, chicken, and roasted red peppers.
With an array of creative Pizza Toppings, OH Pizza Brew transforms the ordinary into extraordinary, making it a must-visit for locals craving flavorful innovation.
Fibonacci Pizzeria
Fibonacci Pizzeria stands out not only for its inviting ambiance within a vintage movie theater but also for its innovative topping combinations that cater to diverse palates.
The mastery of Neapolitan-style cooking techniques guarantees that each pizza is crafted with precision, offering a delightful balance of flavors and textures.
This cozy dining atmosphere enhances the overall experience, making it a perfect spot for both casual outings and special occasions.
Unique Topping Combinations
Exploring the unique topping combinations at Fibonacci Pizzeria reveals a creative culinary landscape that challenges traditional pizza norms.
Their innovative approach embraces unconventional ingredients and creative flavor pairings, resulting in memorable pies. Highlights include:
- Dill Pickle & Bacon: A garlic EVOO base complemented by dill pickle slices and bacon, offering a tangy crunch.
- Buffalo Chicken Blue Cheese: Fire braised chicken and blue cheese crumbles harmonize with buffalo sauce for a spicy kick.
- Prosciutto & Figs: An elegant blend of goat cheese, organic figs, and arugula, drizzled with fig glaze, showcases sophistication.
Fibonacci Pizzeria's adventurous toppings invite diners to explore bold flavors, redefining what pizza can be, and ensuring a delightful experience with each bite.
Neapolitan-Style Cooking Technique
While many pizzerias may offer a variety of styles, the authentic Neapolitan cooking technique employed at Fibonacci Pizzeria elevates the pizza experience through its meticulous approach to high-temperature baking and ingredient selection.
Central to this method is dough hydration, which typically ranges from 65% to 75%, creating a balance between a soft interior and a crispy exterior. The use of a pizza stone further enhances moisture control, absorbing excess moisture during the rapid cooking process.
With pizzas baked for just 1 to 2 minutes in a wood-fired oven, Fibonacci achieves an ideal crust texture while preserving the integrity of fresh, high-quality toppings.
This commitment to technique guarantees that each pizza is a flavorful, artisanal masterpiece worthy of celebration.
Cozy Dining Atmosphere
Nestled within the charming confines of Studio 35 Cinema & Drafthouse, Fibonacci Pizzeria offers a unique dining experience that seamlessly blends the nostalgia of a vintage movie theater with the vibrant atmosphere of a lively bar.
This cozy spot elevates ambiance enhancement, making it ideal for cozy gatherings.
Key features include:
- Diverse Seating Options: Enjoy meals at tables near the bar or within the theater for a casual vibe.
- Charming Decor: Adorned with twinkling Christmas lights, the ambiance is warm and inviting.
- Delicious Offerings: From wood-fired pizzas to creative cocktails, the menu caters to diverse tastes.
Whether it's a movie night or a casual dinner, Fibonacci Pizzeria creates memorable experiences that delight the senses.
Tommy's Pizza
Tommy's Pizza stands as a hallmark of Columbus's culinary landscape, having been a beloved establishment since its founding in 1952 by Thomas Iacono.
With its iconic history rooted in community service, Tommy's has become a staple for generations of families and students alike.
Originally located on Fifth Avenue, the pizzeria has expanded to include locations in Upper Arlington and Dublin, all while maintaining its commitment to quality.
Known for its thin-crust, square-cut pizzas and diverse menu, which includes specialty pies and toasted subs, Tommy's embodies the spirit of Columbus.
Ranked 5th among the best pizzerias, it continues to thrive, proving that exceptional pizza can indeed foster lasting community connections.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do These Pizzerias Offer Gluten-Free Crust Options?
Many pizzerias in Columbus provide gluten-free crust options, featuring diverse toppings and varying crust textures. Notable establishments like Harvest Pizzeria and Paulie Gee's Short North guarantee inclusivity for gluten-sensitive patrons, enhancing their dining experiences with quality selections.
Are Any of These Pizzerias Kid-Friendly?
Several pizzerias in Columbus prioritize a family atmosphere, offering dedicated kids' menus and options that cater to younger diners. Establishments such as East Coast Pizzeria and Dewey's Pizza create inviting environments for families.
What Are the Average Price Ranges at These Pizzerias?
In the domain of culinary delights, pizzerias present a spectrum of price ranges, from $8.25 for simple toppings in cozy atmospheres to gourmet experiences exceeding $20, inviting patrons to savor both taste and ambiance.
Do Any Pizzerias Provide Delivery Services?
Numerous pizzerias offer delivery services, implementing delivery fees and order tracking systems to enhance customer convenience. This modern approach caters to evolving consumer preferences, ensuring timely service and transparency throughout the pizza ordering experience.
Are There Vegetarian or Vegan Options Available?
Numerous pizzerias offer diverse vegetarian and vegan options, allowing for personalized topping preferences. Ingredients are often sourced thoughtfully, enhancing the culinary experience while catering to dietary choices, ensuring inclusivity for those seeking flavorful plant-based alternatives.
