Pittsburgh boasts a dynamic pizza scene, highlighting local favorites that cater to diverse tastes. Pizzeria Davide offers authentic Italian flavors with unique toppings, while Caliente Pizza and Draft House is celebrated for its award-winning pan pizzas. Shelly Pie delights with traditional options, and Alberta's Pizzeria enhances flavors through wood-fired cooking. Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room pairs signature pizzas with a robust craft beer selection. For a late-night treat, Benny Fierro's massive offerings impress. With each pizzeria showcasing something special, Steel City locals have plenty to savor. Explore these beloved spots further for an unforgettable pizza journey.
Pizzeria Davide
Nestled in the heart of Pittsburgh's vibrant Strip District, Pizzeria Davide stands as a beacon for pizza enthusiasts seeking authentic Italian flavors. This charming establishment offers a welcoming pizzeria atmosphere, perfect for unwinding with friends or family. Their menu boasts an impressive array of pizza styles, including Old World and New York favorites, available in sizes ranging from 12 to 20 inches. What truly sets Pizzeria Davide apart are its creative pizza toppings, such as soppressata, mushrooms, and prosciutto paired with arugula. Diners can also indulge in savory appetizers, delectable sandwiches, and delightful desserts. With a reputation for quality and service, Pizzeria Davide is a must-visit destination for those craving a taste of true Italian craftsmanship in every bite. Takeout available adds to the convenience, making it easy to enjoy their delicious offerings at home.
Caliente Pizza and Draft House
Caliente Pizza and Draft House is renowned for its award-winning pan pizzas, including the celebrated Mee-Maw Pizza, which earned accolades as Best Pizza in America in 2019.
In addition to its exceptional pizza offerings, the establishment boasts a diverse selection of craft beers, making it a popular destination for both pizza enthusiasts and beer aficionados. With free small 1-topping pizza available for those who join their email list, customers can enjoy even more value when dining at Caliente.
With multiple locations throughout Pittsburgh, Caliente continues to impress with its commitment to quality and innovation.
Award-Winning Pan Pizza
Renowned for its exceptional culinary creations, Caliente Pizza and Draft House has made a significant mark in the pizza landscape of Pittsburgh, particularly with its award-winning pan pizzas.
At the heart of these delectable offerings is their signature dough, expertly crafted to deliver a perfect crust. The menu boasts crowd-pleasers like the Luca Brasi, featuring crushed plum tomato sauce, sweet sausage, and a medley of roasted peppers, and the acclaimed Mee-Maw Pizza, celebrated as the Best Pizza in America in 2019. Additionally, customers rave about the family-friendly dining environment that enhances their overall experience.
Another standout, The Quack Attack, shines with pan-seared duck breast and truffle garlic oil, earning accolades at the International Pizza Expo.
Each pie is adorned with award-winning toppings, ensuring a unique and satisfying dining experience that keeps patrons returning for more.
Diverse Beer Selection
Regularly celebrated for its impressive array of craft beers, Caliente Pizza and Draft House offers a diverse selection that perfectly complements its culinary offerings.
Each location features a unique tap list, showcasing standout brews like the signature Hazy Dough Dazy IPA and the bold Crust Crusher Double IPA. Frequent updates guarantee patrons can explore various styles, from the invigorating Curious George Shandy in Monroeville to the rich Sierra Nevada Pale Ale in North Hills.
With a commitment to supporting local breweries, Caliente curates an engaging beer menu that enhances the dining experience. Additionally, they offer gluten-friendly beer options to ensure all guests can find a brew that suits their needs.
Whether relaxing outdoors or enjoying a family-friendly atmosphere, guests can savor the perfect pairing of exceptional craft beer and delicious pizza, making each visit a memorable one.
Shelly Pie
While many pizzerias in Pittsburgh offer a diverse array of options, Shelly Pie stands out for its commitment to quality and flavor in traditional pizza.
With a rich history rooted in homemade recipes, this beloved establishment serves large traditional and Sicilian pizzas, perfect for sharing. Diners rave about the variety of Shelly Pie flavors, including beloved options like Buffalo Chicken and classic pepperoni. However, some have noted that the Sicilian crust can be overly doughy. The extensive menu also features hoagies, salads, and daily specials, ensuring that there's something for everyone. The smallest traditional pizza measures 13 inches, making it a great option for those looking for a satisfying meal.
With friendly service and a welcoming ambiance, Shelly Pie has become a staple for locals seeking the perfect pie in the Steel City.
Alberta's Pizzeria
Alberta's Pizzeria stands out in Pittsburgh's vibrant food scene with its commitment to wood-fired cooking, which imparts a distinctive flavor and texture to its Neapolitan-inspired pizzas. This artisanal technique not only enhances the dining experience but also emphasizes the quality of the fresh, seasonal ingredients used in each dish. In addition, Alberta's offers affordable pricing options, making it accessible for pizza lovers looking to indulge without breaking the bank. The restaurant also benefits from the trucking industry's contribution to the local economy, ensuring fresh ingredients are delivered efficiently.
Wood-Fired Cooking Technique
At Alberta's Pizzeria, the art of wood-fired cooking brings a unique depth of flavor to each pizza, setting it apart from conventional methods.
The process begins with careful ember management, ensuring a rolling flame is maintained for ideal cooking temperatures of 400°C to 450°C. After a meticulous pre-heating of two to three hours using hardwood—chosen for its clean-burning properties—the pizzas are placed strategically close to the flame. Additionally, the floor temperature should reach approximately 400°C to ensure an even cook.
Expert dough handling is essential; the 10-12 inch dough is rolled with care to avoid tears. Toppings are evenly distributed, and pizzas are rotated regularly within the oven's dome, creating a perfect char in just 90 seconds to two minutes.
This harmonious technique results in a truly exceptional pizza experience.
Affordable Pricing Options
Nestled in the heart of Pittsburgh, Alberta's Pizzeria offers a delightful range of affordable dining options that cater to diverse palates and budgets.
Their menu features enticing small plates and shared items, such as tostones, zucchini frites, and fresh salads, allowing for customizable, budget-friendly dining experiences. Pizza remains a staple food choice for many residents, reflecting the city's diverse pizza styles and preferences.
Although specific pizza prices are not detailed, patrons often find ordering multiple wood-fired pizzas manageable, thanks to consistent pricing across their offerings.
Collaborations with local breweries enhance the experience with reasonably priced craft beers and unique cocktails.
With a selection of wines by the glass, Alberta's Pizzeria elevates affordable menu options without compromising quality.
Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room
Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room stands out as a culinary gem in Pittsburgh's Cultural District, offering patrons an exceptional dining experience that combines a trendy ambiance with high-quality wood-fired pizzas. The establishment prides itself on its brick oven techniques, producing perfectly charred crusts while maintaining the authenticity of Italian ingredients.
- Unique Flavors: Pizzas like Pesto with bacon and Calabrian with pancetta elevate traditional recipes. Additionally, guests can indulge in a variety of desserts, including Choc Gellato and Tiramisu Cheesecake, to satisfy their sweet cravings.
- Craft Beer Selection: With 30 craft beers on tap, the tap room atmosphere enhances the overall dining experience.
- Community Engagement: Actively participates in local initiatives, providing meals to those in need.
Whether for a pre-show meal or a casual night out, Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room is a must-visit for pizza aficionados and craft beer lovers alike.
Papa J's Twin Plaza
Papa J's Twin Plaza offers an inviting atmosphere in Pittsburgh's vibrant Strip District, where patrons can indulge in a diverse menu of Italian cuisine. This full-service restaurant is celebrated for its handmade pastas and freshly made gelato, presenting a delightful culinary experience. Guests can savor popular dishes like Chicken Marsala and Spinach and Feta Pasta, which perfectly complement the Roman Style Pizza, available at an attractive price. The gelato flavors are invigorating, providing a sweet conclusion to any meal. With a commendable 4-star rating on Yelp, Papa J's is praised for its excellent service and ambiance. Dine-in only for special menu items during Restaurant Week adds to the appeal, ensuring diners enjoy an unforgettable outing in this bustling locale. Reservations are recommended, especially during the busy Restaurant Week, ensuring diners enjoy an unforgettable outing in this bustling locale.
Pizza Parma
Pizza Parma stands out in Pittsburgh's culinary landscape not only for its diverse Italian menu but also for its expertise in corporate catering, making it a go-to choice for business events.
With a focus on quick pizza options, patrons can enjoy a variety of specialty pizzas that cater to all tastes, from classic to innovative flavors.
The convenience of curbside pickup further enhances its appeal, ensuring a seamless dining experience for both individuals and groups.
Corporate Catering Expertise
Frequently chosen by local businesses for their corporate catering needs, Pizza Parma excels in delivering a wide array of culinary options that cater to diverse professional gatherings.
Their expertise in catering logistics guarantees seamless service, while menu customization allows for tailored experiences that accommodate various dietary preferences.
- Diverse Options: From personal pizzas to group spreads, there's something for everyone.
- Quality Assurance: Commitment to exceptional food and service guarantees satisfaction.
- Professional Experience: Their seasoned team understands the nuances of corporate events.
Whether it's a casual lunch or an elaborate celebration, Pizza Parma's flexibility and attention to detail make them an ideal choice for any corporate occasion, guaranteeing that each gathering is not only delicious but memorable.
Quick Pizza Options
For those seeking quick and satisfying meal options, Pizza Parma stands out as a top choice in Pittsburgh. Renowned for its quick service, this pizzeria caters to both busy professionals and late-night cravings with operating hours from 10:00 AM to 2:00 AM.
With multiple locations in Downtown and Shadyside, Pizza Parma offers convenient curbside pickup and online ordering, making it easy to enjoy a delicious meal on the go. Their menu features an enticing variety of pizzas, including specialty options like the Mediterranean and Spinach & Chicken, along with the flexibility to build your own.
Regular deals and special offers enhance the experience, ensuring that quality and affordability are always within reach. Experience the freedom of quick, flavorful dining at Pizza Parma.
Diverse Italian Menu
At the heart of Pizza Parma's offerings lies a diverse Italian menu that caters to a wide array of tastes and preferences.
This establishment prides itself on incorporating authentic Italian ingredients and seasonal variations, ensuring each dish is a celebration of flavor.
- Wood Fired and Traditional Pizzas: A delightful fusion of cooking styles that brings out the best in each ingredient.
- Handmade Pastas: Crafted using seasonal ingredients, these pasta dishes showcase Italy's rich culinary heritage.
- Catering Services: Perfectly tailored for corporate events and gatherings, bringing a taste of Italy to any occasion.
Pizza Parma stands out in Pittsburgh's vibrant pizzeria scene, offering an authentic experience that reflects the city's rich Italian culinary traditions.
V3 Pizza
V3 Pizza's inviting atmosphere and innovative approach to pizza-making make it a standout destination in Pittsburgh's vibrant culinary scene.
Located at 4500 Butler Street, this fast-casual pizza shop empowers customers to craft their own pizza masterpieces. With extensive customization options, diners can select from various doughs, sauces, toppings, and finishes—all for one low price.
For those seeking quick, satisfying meals, V3 Pizza also offers suggested creations like the BBQ Pit Boss and Margherita V.
Significantly, the menu features gluten-free choices alongside traditional offerings, ensuring inclusivity for all dietary preferences.
With friendly staff and a BYOB policy, V3 Pizza is perfect for casual lunches or lively dinners, making it a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts in the Steel City.
Benny Fierro's
In the heart of Pittsburgh's South Side, Benny Fierro's stands out as a beloved late-night pizzeria known for its generous slices and welcoming ambiance. Established in 2015, Benny's has carved a niche in the late-night scene, serving massive 28-inch pizzas that invite camaraderie among friends after a night out.
- Benny's History: Part of the Benny's Pizza chain, it emphasizes simplicity and affordability.
- Community Involvement: Actively engages in local events and partnerships, bolstering neighborhood spirit.
- Menu Highlights: Offers an array of high-quality options, including cheese, pepperoni, and mushroom slices.
With its BYOB policy and quick service, Benny Fierro's is not just a pizzeria; it's a staple of South Side nightlife, where locals gather for the ultimate pizza experience.
Fiori's Pizzaria
Located a short drive from the vibrant South Side, Fiori's Pizzaria has been a cherished destination for pizza lovers since 1979.
This family-owned establishment is renowned for its hand-tossed excellence, creating a perfect crust that serves as the foundation for a variety of traditional Italian dishes. Patrons can savor classic pizzas, calzones, and an array of pastas, all crafted with authentic ingredients and a touch of love.
Fiori's offers a welcoming atmosphere, ideal for family dinners or casual take-out. With two locations in Pittsburgh and McMurray, it's easy to indulge in their delectable offerings.
Highly rated by customers, Fiori's stands out as a pillar of the Steel City's vibrant culinary scene, upholding a rich family-owned tradition.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Are the Most Popular Toppings in Pittsburgh Pizzerias?
In a culinary battlefield, Pittsburgh's pizzerias showcase local favorites like pepperoni and sausage, alongside adventurous topping trends including kimchi and lamb. This vibrant tapestry reflects the city's rich Italian-American heritage and innovative spirit.
Are There Gluten-Free Pizza Options Available in These Pizzerias?
Pizzerias in Pittsburgh offer various gluten-free crusts, with some establishments ensuring celiac-friendly options. However, patrons should remain vigilant regarding cross-contamination concerns, as preparation practices may vary among different locations, impacting overall safety and satisfaction.
Do Any Pizzerias Offer Vegan Cheese or Plant-Based Options?
Numerous pizzerias offer exceptional vegan cheese and plant-based options, featuring delightful vegan toppings and plant-based crusts. These establishments cater to diverse dietary preferences, ensuring flavorful experiences for those seeking plant-forward culinary choices.
What Are the Typical Price Ranges for Pizzas in Pittsburgh?
Imagine a vibrant table laden with pizza portion sizes reflecting diverse tastes. In Pittsburgh, small pizzas range from $9.90 to $14.70, while pizza price comparisons reveal medium and large options that cater to every craving.
Are There Any Pizzerias That Offer Delivery Services?
Numerous pizzerias in Pittsburgh offer delivery services, often featuring order tracking and varying delivery fees. Local and national chains alike provide diverse options, enhancing convenience for pizza enthusiasts seeking quality and accessibility in their dining experience.
